Difference between revisions of "Responses to comments"

From LID SWM Planning and Design Guide
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m
Line 4: Line 4:


==Comments and responses==
==Comments and responses==
;Is it possible to get the the planting list updated to include native species?
:


;Is there a reliable set of estimated design infiltration rates for sites where only soil type is currently known? Additional tests will be conducted, but for now we are looking for numbers to begin an estimate, and a reasonable basis for those numbers.
;Is there a reliable set of estimated design infiltration rates for sites where only soil type is currently known? Additional tests will be conducted, but for now we are looking for numbers to begin an estimate, and a reasonable basis for those numbers.
:The curators of Minnesota's stormwater wiki have conducted a very thorough literature review to establish their suggested values for design infiltration rates<ref>Minnesota Stormwater Manual contributors, "Design infiltration rates," Minnesota Stormwater Manual, , https://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php?title=Design_infiltration_rates&oldid=37031 (accessed May 11, 2018).</ref>. The lowest value on their table for clayey soils is 15 mm/hr, we believe that this is a reasonable estimate for clay soils. Designers may wish to add a [[Design_infiltration_rate#Safety correction safety correction]] to this number before undertaking their design calculations.

Revision as of 13:53, 11 May 2018

The original comments may be viewed here Special:ArticleFeedbackv5#. The Mediawiki platform of this guide does not permit them to be easily altered on this page. Below, the comments have been copied and the current curator of the LID guide has made a response. As ever, users of the guide are encouraged to submit their own comment at the bottom of this page.

Comments and responses[edit]

Is it possible to get the the planting list updated to include native species?
Is there a reliable set of estimated design infiltration rates for sites where only soil type is currently known? Additional tests will be conducted, but for now we are looking for numbers to begin an estimate, and a reasonable basis for those numbers.
The curators of Minnesota's stormwater wiki have conducted a very thorough literature review to establish their suggested values for design infiltration rates[1]. The lowest value on their table for clayey soils is 15 mm/hr, we believe that this is a reasonable estimate for clay soils. Designers may wish to add a Design_infiltration_rate#Safety correction safety correction to this number before undertaking their design calculations.
  1. Minnesota Stormwater Manual contributors, "Design infiltration rates," Minnesota Stormwater Manual, , https://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php?title=Design_infiltration_rates&oldid=37031 (accessed May 11, 2018).